Ebook B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, by Marc N Richelle
Certainly, to improve your life quality, every book B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, By Marc N Richelle will certainly have their certain lesson. Nonetheless, having particular awareness will certainly make you really feel much more certain. When you really feel something happen to your life, often, reading book B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, By Marc N Richelle could help you to make calm. Is that your genuine hobby? Occasionally indeed, but occasionally will be uncertain. Your option to read B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, By Marc N Richelle as one of your reading e-books, could be your appropriate book to check out now.
B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, by Marc N Richelle
Ebook B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, by Marc N Richelle
Some people could be laughing when considering you checking out B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, By Marc N Richelle in your leisure. Some might be appreciated of you. As well as some may desire be like you who have reading leisure activity. Exactly what concerning your own feeling? Have you felt right? Reading B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, By Marc N Richelle is a need and a pastime simultaneously. This problem is the on that particular will certainly make you feel that you have to check out. If you understand are trying to find guide qualified B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, By Marc N Richelle as the selection of reading, you could discover here.
Do you ever before know the book B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, By Marc N Richelle Yeah, this is a quite appealing e-book to read. As we told formerly, reading is not type of obligation task to do when we need to obligate. Reading should be a practice, a good routine. By reviewing B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, By Marc N Richelle, you could open up the new globe as well as get the power from the globe. Everything can be gotten with guide B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, By Marc N Richelle Well briefly, e-book is really effective. As what we provide you here, this B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, By Marc N Richelle is as one of checking out book for you.
By reviewing this e-book B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, By Marc N Richelle, you will get the best point to acquire. The new point that you do not need to invest over money to reach is by doing it on your own. So, exactly what should you do now? Visit the link web page and download the book B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, By Marc N Richelle You could get this B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, By Marc N Richelle by online. It's so easy, isn't it? Nowadays, technology truly supports you tasks, this on the internet e-book B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, By Marc N Richelle, is as well.
Be the very first to download this book B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, By Marc N Richelle as well as allow reviewed by finish. It is very simple to read this book B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, By Marc N Richelle considering that you do not need to bring this printed B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, By Marc N Richelle all over. Your soft documents publication can be in our device or computer system so you could appreciate reading almost everywhere as well as each time if needed. This is why lots varieties of individuals likewise read guides B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, By Marc N Richelle in soft fie by downloading guide. So, be one of them which take all benefits of reading the book B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, By Marc N Richelle by on-line or on your soft file system.
B.F. Skinner died in August 1990. He had been praised as one of the most influential psychologists of the 20th century, but was also attacked by a variety of opponents within and outside the field of psychology. This introduction to his work is first of all a guide to a correct reading of his writings, a reading devoid of the distortions and misinterpretations often conveyed by many commentators, including psychologists. It frames Skinner's contributions with reference to major European traditions in psychological sciences, namely Pavlov, Freud, Lorenz and Piaget. Crucial aspects of Skinner's theory and methodological stands are discussed in the context of contemporary debates: special attention is devoted to the relationship of psychology with biology and the neurosciences, to the cognitivist movement, to the status of language and to the explanation of novelty and creativity in human behaviour.; Finally, Skinner's social and political philosophy is presented with an emphasis on the provocative aspects of an analysis of current social practices which fail to solve most of the urgent problems humankind is confronted with today. Both in science proper and in human affairs at large, Skinner's thought is shown to be not behind, as is often claimed, but ahead of the times, be it in his interactive view of linguistic communication, in his very modern use of the evolutionary analogy to explain the dynamics of behaviour, or in his vision of ecological constraints.
- Sales Rank: #3870475 in Books
- Brand: Brand: Psychology Press
- Published on: 1995-07-03
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 9.20" h x .66" w x 5.98" l, .86 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 256 pages
Features
- Used Book in Good Condition
Most helpful customer reviews
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful.
Outside the Skinner Box
By calmly
An exceptional book. Marc Richelle was a student of Skinner's (and Piaget's) and co-translated some of Skinner's works into French. He seems able to identify Skinner's mistakes but also to represent well Skinner's achievements.
One subject Richelle ventures into is why there were so many attacks on Skinner, often misrepresenting his positions badly and at time attacking him personally. In a chapter on language, Richelle considers the vicious attacks by Chomsky and how, by ignoring them, Skinner lost an opportunity to influence psycholinguistics.
Richelle's understanding of the "Skinner box" and "operant conditioning" are liberating. "Operant conditioning" may be misnamed, "operant learning" seems more accurate. Skinner may have needed to isolate rats in boxes so he could understand some basic principles of behavior, but even a rat, outside a box, displays a rich set of behavior which we can not predict. The box is a reflection of Skinner's limitation, that he could't grasp the full richness of our behavior or a rats, so he needed the help of the box and its simple environment for a while to get a start on how organism's behave. Skinner appreciated how rich the behavior of orgnanism is, but he also appreciated how much scientific understanding of how we behave could benefit us.
Richelle's discussion of Skinner's social concerns may be the strongest part of this book, as evidenced by Skinner's writings and inventions on education, by his concern for the plight of woman, and by his concern for all of us who have been duped into maintaining the status quo. Richelle shows how, seemingly paradoxicaly, the belief in our autonomy encouraged in us by controlling agencies like the government, works to keep us ineffective and under oppressive controls.
Would this book function well as an introduction to Skinner, as Richelle himself intended? Anyone, including a lay reader, might benefit from reading some of Skinner first, for example "Walden Two" or "Beyond Freedom And Dignity". But Skinner's ideas may seem too foreign without preparation by a good guide such as Marc Richelle. On the other hand, Richelle himself is fairly challenging. If you haven't read Skinner and are interested, I suggest you choose yourself whether to start with Skinner or Richelle. If your choice seems like tough reading, try switching to the other. One way or the other, getting to understand Skinner may be one of the best things you ever did for yourself. The more of us who have at least some scientific understanding of behavior, the better for all of us.
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful.
A European take on Skinner
By Jim Farmelant
Marc Richelle is a Belgian psychologist who studied in Geneva where, not surprisingly, he came under the influence of Piaget. However, as he began to read B.F. Skinner's work his viewpoint shifted towards radical behaviorism while still retaining a great respect for Piaget. His book, *B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal*, is written as an evaluation of Skinner from the standpoint of a European psychologist, and he relates Skinner's work with that of such prominent European psychologists as Pavlov, Freud, Lorenz, Piaget, and Vygotsky. Richelle provides an overview of Skinner's career and how his views evolved over time. For those who are familiar with Skinner's work much of this should be familiar, but they still might learn a good deal from Richelle's comparison of Skinner to his European contemporaries. Richelle's evaluation of Skinner in reference to European psychology makes his book unique among the studies of Skinner's work.
Richelle sketches out Skinner's contributions to experimental methodology in psychology, including the invention of the Skinner box and the development of a research methodology based on single-organism experiments, as opposed to the traditional method of comparing experimental groups with control groups. He reviews Skinner's challenge to traditional S-R models of behavior, those psychologies that Skinner labeled methodological behaviorisms. Such psychologies include the behaviorisms of John B. Watson and Clark Hull as well as the cognitive school of psychology. For all these schools, psychology is in one way or another the science which attempts to understand behavior in terms of stimulus-response pairings. This is true even for the cognitivists, who differ only in that they posit intervening cognitive mechanisms between stimulus and response. Against these schools, Skinner posited his own radical behaviorism which centered around his conception of operant conditioning (a conception that owed much to the work of Thorndike on the Law of Effect). In his elaboration of operant mechanisms, Skinner proposed to understand the development of behavior in Darwinian terms - that is, the selection of responses by the organism's environment.
Richelle devotes one chapter to exploring Skinner's debt to Pavlov, which was certainly very large. Skinner borrowed much of his scientific vocabulary from Pavlov as well some of his methodology. However, contrary to Pavlov, Skinner contended that there were two types of conditioning rather than one: traditional Pavlovian conditioning (which he called respondent conditioning) and operant conditioning. Although both kinds of conditioning followed similar laws, there were also significant differences which required the use of different experimental methodologies. Skinner argued that the two types of conditioning had different neuroanatomical roots, with Pavlovian conditioning rooted in the autonomic nervous system and operant conditioning rooted in the somatic nervous system. This thesis was eventually refuted by Neal Miller in 1968 when he showed that, contrary to Skinner, autonomic responses could be operantly conditioned (1).
Concerning the influence of Pavlov on Skinner, Richelle concludes that, while large, it has been overstated by many commentators.
Richelle devotes a chapter to Freud in Skinner's writings. He notes that while Skinner was highly critical of Freud's mentalism, he had many kind things to say about Freud's work. Skinner admired Freud for being a determinist, for being an astute observer of human behavior, and for having discarded consciousness and introspection as tools for understanding mental processes. Freud was praised by Skinner for having shown that mental activity does not require consciousness and that many of the most important aspects of mental activity occur beyond its ken. Skinner saw much value in the concepts of Freudian defense mechanisms (i.e., repression, sublimation, projection, rationalization) which in *Science and Human Behavior* and *Verbal Behavior* he sought to show could be translated into the language of behaviorism.
Skinner also argued that Freud's modeling of human personality in terms of id, ego, and superego could be restated in terms of the various sorts of contingencies of reinforcement that control human behaviors. Thus the Freudian id was seen as corresponding to biologically based reinforcers and was responsible for behaviors that were ultimately reinforced by food, water, sexual contact and other primary biological reinforcers. The superego - the "conscience" of Judeo-Christian theology - was in turn responsible for the behaviors that control the id, using techniques of self-control that are acquired from the group. Id and superego inevitably clash, and their conflicts are in turn mediated by the ego, which besides attempting to reach a compromise between the id and superego also deals with the practical exigencies of the environment.
Richelle goes on to discuss Skinner and ethology, especially that of Konrad Lorenz. Skinner was often harshly critical of much of the work of the ethologists, including Lorenz, but he came to perceive the value of their work. He agreed with them concerning the necessity of applying a Darwinian standpoint to behavior (which meant understanding it in selectionist terms) but he faulted them for not making a clear distinction between different levels - the biological level, the behavioral level, and in humans the cultural level - to which a Darwinian analysis could be applied. (Interestingly, Skinner faulted the sociobiologists on similar grounds.) Skinner's comments on the three levels of selectionism is relevant to such matters as the debate over directionality in history which Robert Wright defends in his book *Nonzero* and which is also defended by Alan Carling from the standpoint of a selectionist Marxism (2).
Concerning Piaget, Richelle says that both Skinner and Piaget were largely ignorant of each other's work, a situation which he finds to have been understandable but somewhat regrettable, since in certain respects their perspectives were more complementary rather than antagonistic. Piaget's constructivism was explicitly developmentalist, an approach that Richelle sees Skinner as having under-emphasized. Also, Piaget's work was concerned with the development of the higher cognitive functions in humans, whereas Skinner's work tended to focus on those aspects of behavior that humans share with other species. But despite the fact that they came out of quite different psychological traditions, there were some underlying similarities, in Richelle's opinion. Both men attempted to take Darwinism seriously, which meant understanding behavior in evolutionist, selectionist terms. Skinner's emphasis on knowledge as action was surprisingly similar to Piaget's views. Richelle at one point compares quotations from Skinner and Piaget. From Skinner's *About Behaviorism* he quotes:
"Operant behavior is essentially the exercise of a power: it has an effect on the environment."
Likewise, Richelle quotes from Piaget's *Adaptation vitale et psychologies de l'intelligence*:
"The organism acts upon the environment, rather than being simply submitted to it. As to the highest levels, where behavior plays a non-negligible role, this role is by no means limited to compensate for alterations or aggressions from the environment: it may consist, on the contrary, in conquering actions aimed at extending the environment."
Richelle points out that for both Piaget and Skinner the emphasis in studying behavior was not on the stimulus, nor upon the mind, but rather upon action itself.
Richelle argues that Piaget's work on cognitive development could have benefited from a greater understanding of Skinner's work on operant learning since, like Skinner, he was committed to applying Darwinian analogies to the understanding of behavior. Skinner's analysis of operant conditioning could have helped Piaget to substantiate his thesis that evolution, or selectionism, is applicable to behavior on a multiplicity of levels.
Richelle only very briefly discusses the work of the Soviet psychologist Vygotsky, but he notes some similarities to Skinner, including the fact that both Vygotsky's psychology of activity and Skinner's radical behaviorism shared an emphasis on action as the focus for psychological study. They also shared similar views concerning the social origins of human self-awareness.
Richelle has a useful chapter on the Skinner-Chomsky debate in psycholinguistics. He agrees with Skinner that Chomsky fundamentally misunderstood Skinner's work, but he also faults Skinner for, among other things, neglecting the developmental dimension which Chomsky emphasized, for failing to respond to Chomsky's attacks, and for failing to engage the psycholinguists generally. However, Richelle discerns a tendency within psycholinguistics to move towards positions reminiscent of Skinner's without generally acknowledging the Skinnerian origins of the views that they are adopting.
The last few chapters of the book engage Skinner's views on education and society. Richelle generally endorses most of them with enthusiasm and he gives a good restatement of the arguments of *Beyond Freedom and Dignity*. Richelle reiterates Skinner's critique of "autonomous man" and how this notion, along with commonsense mentalistic psychology, performs an important ideological function: persuading people that they are free agents while concealing the existence of behavioral controls. This wouldn't be so bad, Richelle thinks, except that the types of behavioral controls in place have failed to solve our most important social problems. Therefore, Richelle agrees with Skinner that a challenge to the notions of autonomous man and mentalism is necessary if we are to make social progress.
One section of this chapter bears the heading "Mentalism as a Tool of Power," which sums up Richelle's (and Skinner's) point regarding control. Mentalism promotes the idea that the way toward change is to change people's minds or hearts, not the environmental conditions in which they live. This generally suits the dominant political and economic elites, since mentalism turns people's attention inwards, diverting them from perceiving the actual determinants of their lives, especially the more or less hidden behavioral controls. By positing a special freedom, the myth of autonomous man conditions the masses to blame themselves for their fate, and the status quo is thus rendered safe from questioning or modification. No surprise, then, that Skinner, even with Richelle's advocacy, is unlikely to catch on.
Notes:
(1). Miller's research on the operant conditioning of visceral responses provided the scientific basis for biofeedback research which enjoyed a particular vogue in the 1970s. See: Miller, N.E. and Banuazizi, A., 1968. Instrumental learning by curarized rats of a specific visceral response, intestinal, or cardiac. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology, 65: 1-7. See also Miller, N.E. and Dworkin, B.R., 1973. Visceral learning: Recent difficulties with curarized rats and significant programs for human research. In Oberist, P.A. et al. (eds.) Contemporary Trends in Cardiovascular Psychophysiology. Chicago: Aldine-Atherton.
(2). Carling, Alan, 1993. "Analytical Marxism and Historical Materialism: The Debate on Social Evolution." Science & Society, 57:1 (Spring), 31-65. Carling, Alan, 1994. "The Strength of Historical Materialism: A Comment." Science & Society, 58:1 (Spring), 60-72.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful.
Looking Good
By Dr Jack L Edwards
Although I purchased the book as a reference text for a number of issues related to radical behaviorism, I have had a chance to look over several items in the book and have not been disappointed. Although much of Chomsky's criticism of Skinner's verbal behavior has been answered and Chomsky shown to be little more than a distraction, albeit for far too long, this book added to my insights over this controversy. There are many more issues covered in the book and I certainly recommend it as a reference on the variety of issues it covers.
The physical quality of the book itself could be better. I have a feeling that it won't sustain too many readings before it starts to come apart, but I could be wrong.
See all 3 customer reviews...
B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, by Marc N Richelle PDF
B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, by Marc N Richelle EPub
B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, by Marc N Richelle Doc
B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, by Marc N Richelle iBooks
B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, by Marc N Richelle rtf
B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, by Marc N Richelle Mobipocket
B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, by Marc N Richelle Kindle
[K918.Ebook] Ebook B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, by Marc N Richelle Doc
[K918.Ebook] Ebook B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, by Marc N Richelle Doc
[K918.Ebook] Ebook B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, by Marc N Richelle Doc
[K918.Ebook] Ebook B.F. Skinner: A Reappraisal, by Marc N Richelle Doc
